The history of Easter Hill United Methodist Church begins in the late forties and early fifties, when there was a need for a church on the South side of Richmond California. A small group of people met to explore the possibilities of forming a church and Rev. Fred H. Busher, pastor of St. Luke's Church, suggested the organization of a Methodist Church. On November 7, 1950, a banquet was held as the first fund raising activity and $1,600 was raised, which was used to buy the property at 30th and Hoffman Blvd. "The Little Brown Church”.
Rev. Dixon served as the first pastor, followed by Rev. S. D. Rhone, Rev. Carr and Rev. W. B. Smith. Easter Hill as a church was becoming a reality, although not formally organized. The church’s name was chosen due to its location. There was a hill between 28th Street and Hoffman Blvd. which served as the Easter Sunrise Worship site. The Easter Hill housing development was also nearby, so the name Easter Hill was assumed.
On February 15, 1951, Rev. Wilbur R. Johnson became the first pastor of the newly organized church. Rev. Busher wanted a non-denominational community church to embrace both Baptist and Methodist members. Rev. Johnson persuaded Rev. Busher and others to recognize the church's Methodist roots and call the new congregation what it really was, a United Methodist Church. Rev. Johnson became the founding and first pastor of the Easter Hill United Methodist Church.
In 1956 land was purchased at 39th and Cutting Blvd., and on December 25, 1957 the first worship service was held in the newly built Easter Hill United Methodist Church. Pastor Johnson served Easter Hill until June of 1959.